Editorial policy: how games get listed and ranked

This is where we explain which games we list, how a listing gets made and how player votes turn into rankings. A game has to meet every rule below to get in, and from then on its place is up to the players.

What gets listed

We only list a game when every one of these is true.

  • Playable

    A browser build that loads, or a downloadable build with a public repository.

  • Substantially AI-made

    The creator says so, or the rules of the jam it was made for require it.

  • A gameplay loop

    A goal, feedback and a way to win or lose. A tech demo on its own isn't enough.

  • Safe to play

    No malware or phishing, no crypto miners, no adult or hateful content, and no collecting personal data without a reason.

  • Fit for a general audience

    No real-money betting or crypto payouts, no game built around a current war or party politics, and no premise that mocks a group of people.

  • Not a duplicate

    A fork needs meaningful changes to be listed on its own.

How a game gets listed

Some games come from creators who submit them, and we find others in game jams and on GitHub. Every game is reviewed before it's listed, and nothing is published automatically.

We don't score games ourselves, and that's kind of the point, because the rankings come from player ratings instead.

Where games play

A game plays in our player, right on its page here, only when its maker allows it. That means they submitted it, their own page shows its badge, or they asked us. Every other game opens on the creator's site.

Games that show ads of their own always open on the creator's site.

How ratings and rankings work

Players rate games from 1 to 5 stars, with one vote per device.

So that one early vote can't put a new game on top, the rankings use a Bayesian average. Basically, each game starts from a prior, a starting score worth 10 votes, and player ratings take over as votes come in.

A game from a ranked jam
The prior is its jam placement, from 5 for first place down to 2.5 for last place.
Every other game
The prior is the middle of the ranked jam games we list, now 4.23, so a new game counts as average until players say otherwise.
Equal scores
When two games have exactly the same score, the one with the higher starting score, before rounding, goes first, then A to Z by title. A placement only breaks ties: it never outranks a better score from votes.
Weekly and monthly lists
Only games with at least three ratings in that period.
Trending
Plays and ratings over the last seven days.

With one 5-star vote, a new game's ranking score becomes (4.23 × 10 + 5) ÷ 11, about 4.30, so it moves up a little without landing on top. The stars on a game's page show the plain average of its votes.

Spotlight, the creator program and referral links

Spotlight slots are always labeled, and of course they never change a game's rating, rank or place in the top lists. Games whose own page links to their page here take turns in them and get a Verified creator tick, and the creator program explains how that works. Any link counts, even a nofollow one.

YouTube videos that link to a game's page here show up on that page once we've reviewed them, our own videos included. Their titles and channel names are the channels' own.

Some guides link to tools through referral links, which may earn us credits when someone signs up. We mark them where they appear. A referral never changes what a guide says, and tools don't pay to be covered.

How descriptions and screenshots are made

Descriptions are drafted with the help of AI from the creator's own materials, then reviewed with the rest of the entry before they're published. Claims about how a game was made always name their source.

Creators can send up to 3 screenshots with a submission, and those become the game's cover and screenshots once they're reviewed with the rest of the entry. For every other game, we take our own.

How guides and posts are made

Guides and posts are drafted with the help of AI and researched from primary sources, which means the makers' own documentation, release notes, pricing pages and jam rules. Every claim about what a tool, model or engine can do links the page it comes from, and the date on each guide is when we last checked it.

Numbers about games come from the catalog itself and update every time the site is built, so a guide never quotes a stale count. We don't accept payment to cover a tool, and referral links are marked where they appear.

Tools change a lot, so when one does, or a reader spots a mistake, we update the page and its date. Corrections go to hello@gamesbyai.win.

Getting a listing fixed or removed

If something on a page is wrong, or you want a game removed, the page on takedown and correction requests says what to send. We handle requests within 48 hours, and you can even suggest a fix yourself in the open catalog on GitHub.